• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Menu
    • Cakes
    • Mini Cakes
    • Cupcakes
    • Other Desserts
    • Frosting Options
    • Grab ‘n Go Desserts
    • Cake Prices and Finish Options
  • Occasions
    • Seasonal Desserts
    • Birthday
    • Weddings
    • Other Celebrations
    • Showers
    • Graduation
    • Religious Events
  • Weddings
  • About Us
  • Contact
Craig's Cake Shop

Craig's Cake Shop

  • (608) 848-6331
  • Start an Order
  • Schedule a Tasting
  • Cake Prices
  • Start an Order
  • Wedding Cakes

Cake Prices and Finish Options

Every cake is made to order. The prices below will help you estimate your budget before submitting an order. Final pricing depends on the cake size, finish, fillings, colors and artwork you select. After reviewing your request, we will send you a final quote before your order is confirmed.

Choose Your Finish

Signature Frosting with White Chocolate Shavings

Signature Frosting with white chocolate shavings on the top and sides. Because this finish does not have a smooth surface, it cannot accommodate writing or artwork.

Smooth Buttercream Top and Shavings

A smooth buttercream top with Signature Frosting and white chocolate shavings on the sides. The smooth top can accommodate writing, an edible image or artwork on top of the cake.

Mini Style Mousse with Chocolate Curls

Our standard cakes have flavored mousse between the cake layers and Signature Frosting on the outside. With the Mini Style finish, the same flavored mousse also covers the outside of the cake and is finished with chocolate curls instead of white chocolate shavings. This recreates the popular style and flavor of our mini cakes in a larger size. The Mini Style finish adds $8 to $24 to the All Shavings price, depending on the cake size.

All-Buttercream Smooth Top and Textured Sides

An all-buttercream finish with a smooth top and textured sides. This finish accommodates artwork on top of the cake and is a good choice if you prefer an all-buttercream cake.

Precision Smooth Top and Sides

An all-buttercream finish with a precisely smoothed top and sides. Our decorators smooth the entire cake by hand to create an even surface for artwork. Because this process requires significant additional labor, Precision Smooth is priced higher than our other finishes. This finish is required for artwork on the sides of the cake.

Please note: The tables below show starting prices for All Shavings and the three buttercream finishes. Mini Style is calculated from the All Shavings price plus the size-based Mini Style charge described above. Custom artwork and optional additions are not included.

Round Cake Starting Prices

Cake Size Approximate Servings Signature Frosting with White Chocolate Shavings Smooth Buttercream Top and Shavings All-Buttercream Smooth Top and Textured Sides Precision Smooth Top and Sides
6 inch10$38$45$48$58
8 inch20$55$62$65$85
10 inch30$70$78$82$110
12 inch44$85$95$100$135
14 inch64$115$127$132$175

Serving estimates use portions approximately 1.5 by 2 inches. Actual servings depend on how the cake is cut.

Square and Sheet Cake Starting Prices

Cake Approximate Servings Signature Frosting with White Chocolate Shavings Smooth Buttercream Top and Shavings All-Buttercream Smooth Top and Textured Sides Precision Smooth Top and Sides
8 inch square32$70$78$83$120
Quarter sheet, single layer24$60$70$75$105
Quarter sheet, two layers48$90$100$105$150
Half sheet, single layer48$90$104$110$150
Half sheet, two layers96$165$181$185$245

What May Change the Final Price

  • Custom artwork or sculpting: quoted according to decorator time.
  • Additional filling layers: generally $3 to $12 per layer, depending on cake size.
  • Candy or cookies: generally $4 to $15, depending on cake size.
  • Edible images: $4 to $20, depending on image size.
  • Buttercream color: white is included; chocolate is $5 and other colors are $10.
  • Gluten-free or vegan cakes: add $10.
  • Heart-shaped cakes: add $20 for 6- and 8-inch cakes or $30 for cakes 10 inches and larger.
  • Special details: roses, metallic paint, stacked tiers and other additions are priced separately.

Included at no additional charge: top and bottom borders, text, balloons, polka dots and sprinkles on the border.

Cupcakes and Grab and Go

Preordered Cupcakes

Mousse or buttercream $3 each; tinted $3.25; ombre $3.50; custom-art cupcakes start at $6.

Grab and Go

6-inch cakes $45; 8-inch cakes $65; mini cakes $19 standard or $21 premium; cupcakes $3.50; gluten-free cupcakes $4; push-ups $4.50.

Wedding Cakes

Wedding pricing is separate because wedding serving sizes, additional filling layers, planning, delivery and setup may apply. Please use our Schedule a Tasting form so we can confirm availability and recommend the appropriate service option.

Requesting a Final Quote

Submit our Start an Order form with your event date, serving needs, flavors, finish choice and any inspiration images. We will review the design and our production availability, then send you a final quote. Prices are subject to change until your order is confirmed.

Start an Order
Wedding Cakes

604 West Verona Avenue
Verona, WI, 53593
(608) 848-6331
info@craigscakeshop.com
Tuesday - Friday: 10 am - 6 pm
Saturday: 9 am - 12 pm
Sunday - Monday: Closed
Careers
FAQs
Allergens
Facebook Facebook Instagram Instagram Pinterest Pinterest
Google Reviews
WeddingWire reviews
Designed + Developed by The Digital Ring