Craig’s Cake Shop is located just outside of Madison in Verona, Wisconsin. We have been creating wedding and all occasion cakes since 2000.  Every cake is custom made and every bite is a taste of heaven.  We are proud to be voted Wisconsin Bride magazine’s Best Cakes in 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013 & 2014!

Our cakes are prepared fresh each week for the date of your event.  We require custom orders to be placed at least a week in advance so we can plan our baking schedule.

Procrastinators don’t fret…each week we bake a few extras in popular flavors, so there are some cakes available at the last minute on a first-come, first-served basis.

Best of Award



Also available at Craig’s Cake Shop:
(Ready for walk-ins or can be reserved over the phone.)

ParfaitsCake Parfaits: Push up and enjoy these tasty layers of cake and mousse.  Available in 2 flavors daily: Cookies n Cream (Chocolate cake, French Vanilla mousse and cookie crumbles) & Vanilla Sprinkle (Vanilla cake, French Vanilla mousse and rainbow sprinkles).   Custom orders available for quantities of 9 or more – pick one cake flavor and one mousse.  $4 each, $21 for a half-dozen or $39 for a dozen


Mini CakesMini Cakes: These 4″ delights come in 4 flavors and are ready for walk-ins or can be reserved over the phone.  Choose either Chocolate, Vanilla, Carrot, or Red Velvet.  $12 each


Cake Top CookiesCake Top Cookies: Our Cake Top Cookies are created by combining our cake with other scrumptious ingredients to create a decadent cookie.  Flavors include Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate Chip, Lemon Poppyseed Blueberry, Red Velvet with White Chocolate Chip, Strawberries n Cream (white chocolate chip), Cinnamon and Pumpkin Chocolate Chip (seasonal). Please pre-order for quantities of two dozen or more.  $.50 each or $10 for two dozen.  Trays of 30 assorted cookies available for $15.

Check out the All Occasions > Flavors page for more information.

Want to know more about what is happening around Craig’s Cake Shop?

Become a fan on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.  

Weddings, Wedding VenuesCraig's Cake Shop, Best Wedding Cakes in Milwaukee - 2014 Couples' Choice Award Winner