All custom orders must be finalized one week prior to the pick up date. Changes to existing orders must be submitted a week prior to the pick up date to ensure order accuracy. Craig’s Cake Shop accepts Cash, Debit Card and Credit Card (Mastercard, Visa, Discover). No Checks.
Online orders are accepted through Saturday for the following week. If your cake is needed in less than a week, please give us a call at 608.848.6331.
Each week, we will be baking popular flavors to keep on hand for those last minute orders. They will be filled and ready for frosting, available on a first-come, first-served basis.
For additional details on cake flavors and options please see the flavors page.