Online orders must be placed at least one week in advance.
If your cake is needed in less than a week,
please give us a call at 608.848.6331.


We are doing some upgrades to our website starting the evening of 4/22.
We apologize in advance for any downtime experienced.


All custom orders must be finalized one week prior to the pick up date. Changes to existing orders must be submitted a week prior to the pick up date to ensure order accuracy. Craig’s Cake Shop accepts Cash, Debit Card and Credit Card (Mastercard, Visa, Discover).
No Checks.

For additional details on cake flavors and options please see the flavors page.

*Required fields

Information about you is not shared and we won't spam you, we promise.
CUSTOM ORDERS REQUIRE A WEEK'S NOTICE. IF NEEDING A CAKE WITH LESS THAN A WEEK'S NOTICE YOU MUST CALL 608.848.6331. ONLINE ORDERS WITH LESS THAN A WEEK'S NOTICE MAY NOT BE FILLED. Craig's Cake Shop is open 10am to 6pm Tues-Fri and 9am-12pm on Saturdays. We are closed on Sunday and Monday.
Craig's Cake Shop is open 10am to 6pm Tues-Fri and 9am-12pm on Saturdays.
Added by splitting top layer of cake for an additional charge.
Added to mousse for an additional charge.
Choose either Buttercream Top or All Buttercream if adding Text, Decorations, or Custom Artwork. Signature frosting is a whipped frosting with white chocolate shavings. Signature frosting can not support text or artwork.
**Copyright images are the property of their respective owners and cannot be reproduced without express written permission from the image owner.
Let us know a little somethin' about your cake ideas.
Drop a file here or click to upload Choose File
Maximum upload size: 52.43MB
Use the "Custom Artwork Instructions" area above to tell us your ideas.
Use this area to include an image link website address or URL.
Use this area to give additional comments, questions or further details about your cake order.
Be in the know of our new products, monthly flavors and specials! 1-2 emails per month. Don't worry, your email address is safe with us. We won't share it with anyone else.